PIA vs Mullvad (2026): Two Tested No-Logs Records Compared
Both no-logs claims have been tested: PIA by US subpoenas, Mullvad by a police raid. PIA adds devices and port forwarding; Mullvad adds anonymity.
Head-to-head VPN comparisons that go beyond spec sheets. We line up audit records, independent speed results, features, and pricing side by side — and name a winner for your specific needs.
Both no-logs claims have been tested: PIA by US subpoenas, Mullvad by a police raid. PIA adds devices and port forwarding; Mullvad adds anonymity.
Both are American, and both parents own VPN review sites. PIA backs its claim with subpoenas and audits; Hotspot Shield offers speed and a free tier.
Both offer a free tier without a card and strong audit records. One streams better and refunds; the other is simpler and cheaper over four years.
Both have usable free tiers. Proton’s comes from a non-profit with five published audits; Hotspot Shield’s from Point Wild, which also owns a VPN review site.
Proton VPN proves its no-logs claim with five published audits; PIA with US subpoenas that found nothing. Both have open-source apps and port forwarding.
ExpressVPN runs every server from RAM; PrivateVPN’s are disk-based and unaudited. PrivateVPN answers with price, port forwarding and a free dedicated IP.
Surfshark has two Deloitte reports and no device limit. PrivateVPN has port forwarding, a free dedicated IP and no audit at all. How to choose between them.