Disclosure: VPNFin is reader-supported. If you buy a VPN through links on this page, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never affects our ratings — here’s our full disclosure.
PIA vs AirVPN is a rare match of providers that still offer port forwarding. PIA, owned by Kape and based in the US, has three Deloitte audits in our table, sets no device limit and offers port forwarding, a SOCKS5 proxy and dedicated IPs through an anonymous token system. In court, three federal subpoenas to PIA produced no user data. AirVPN, based in Perugia, Italy, publishes live statistics for every server, runs open-source clients, offers free port forwarding on up to 20 ports and needs no email, our review found. It has no independent audit, allows five devices and fails with major streaming services.
This guide compares them on privacy, torrenting, streaming, devices and fit.
PIA vs AirVPN on Privacy
PIA has Deloitte audits and a court record of subpoenas that produced nothing. AirVPN has no audit, but publishes live server statistics and open-source clients, and left Italy in 2024 rather than run Piracy Shield blocklists. Our AirVPN review explains the trade-off.
Torrenting
Both offer port forwarding: AirVPN free on up to 20 ports, PIA in its apps. PIA adds a SOCKS5 proxy and dedicated IPs. Our port forwarding guide explains why forwarded ports matter for seeders.
Streaming
Reviewers report AirVPN failing on the major platforms, our review notes. PIA’s results vary by service and region; check our Netflix VPN guide for providers that stream more reliably.
Devices
PIA sets no device limit; AirVPN allows five. A router counts as one device on both.
Sign-Up and Payment
AirVPN needs no email and accepts seven cryptocurrencies among its payment options. PIA asks for an account; check its checkout for payment options.
Apps
PIA’s apps cover Windows, Mac, Linux, iOS, Android, Android TV and Fire TV. AirVPN’s Eddie client has twelve tabs of preferences and no graphical client on iOS, our review notes.
Jurisdiction
PIA operates from the US under Kape. Italy, AirVPN’s base, is a Fourteen Eyes member; our review notes data retention there applies to telecoms rather than VPNs. Our VPN ownership guide explains why jurisdiction matters.
Several Countries
Kripesh Adwani’s 2026 review describes a network of 35,000+ servers in 91 countries for PIA. AirVPN publishes its server list with live load for each one.
Linux and Self-Hosting
Both suit Linux. AirVPN’s open-source Eddie client runs there, and its free ports suit home servers. PIA’s Linux app includes the Advanced Kill Switch, Tom’s Guide notes.
Families
A large household fits PIA’s unlimited plan. Five devices on AirVPN suit one person or a couple, unless a router covers the rest of the home.
Speed
Test each on your own line during its refund or short-plan window. AirVPN publishes live load for each server, which helps you pick a quiet one; PIA’s network is large enough to find a nearby server in most regions.
Censored Networks
AirVPN’s Eddie treats every port as its own connection option, which helps where networks block common ports. Check PIA’s apps for their current obfuscation options before travelling.
Quick Check
After connecting, open our VPN test page and confirm the address changed, then test a forwarded port with your client.
Who Each Suits
PIA suits households and seeders who want polished apps and audits. AirVPN suits privacy purists and self-hosters who prefer open-source tools and anonymous sign-up.
Keeping It Updated
After app updates, recheck the kill switch or network lock and your forwarded ports, since updates can reset them.
Privacy on Public Wi-Fi
Both encrypt traffic on shared networks. Turn on the kill switch or network lock before joining hotel or café Wi-Fi. Our public Wi-Fi guide explains the risks.
Support
Check each provider’s support channels during the refund or short-plan window, and keep the replies.
Routers
Both work on routers through manual setups, and a router counts as one device. Our router setup guide explains the trade-offs.
Quick Rule
Audited, polished and unlimited: PIA. Open source, anonymous and 20 free ports: AirVPN. Test AirVPN on its three-day plan.
Court Record
Three federal subpoenas to PIA produced no user data, alongside its Deloitte audits. AirVPN’s record is its 2024 exit from Italy rather than run Piracy Shield blocklists, a choice that cost it a market.
Refunds
PIA offers a 30-day refund. AirVPN’s refund position is unclear, our review found, so its three-day plan is the safe way to test it.
Kill Switch
PIA’s Advanced Kill Switch blocks internet access unless the VPN is connected, Tom’s Guide notes. Check Eddie’s network lock on AirVPN, and test either by switching Wi-Fi off and on.
Is PIA vs AirVPN a Close Call?
For seeders, closer than most. PIA wins on audits, devices and ease of use; AirVPN wins on anonymous sign-up and open-source clients. For a head-to-head, see our TorGuard vs AirVPN comparison.
Who Should Pick Which
Pick PIA for audited privacy, unlimited devices and polished apps with port forwarding. Pick AirVPN for open-source clients, anonymous sign-up and 20 free forwarded ports. Our Surfshark vs AirVPN comparison sets the two side by side.
How We Research
This page draws on our AirVPN review, Tom’s Guide’s PIA review and our audit, device and refund tables. We cross-checked these sources against each other, and where they conflict or something can’t be verified, we say so in the text rather than guessing. We checked time-sensitive figures, including prices in US dollars, on 8 October 2026. The main source we relied on is AirVPN’s site. Our full approach lives on the About Us page.
PIA vs AirVPN FAQ
PIA for most users; AirVPN for technical users who value open source.
Yes; AirVPN on up to 20 ports, PIA in its apps.
PIA, by Deloitte; AirVPN has no audit.
PIA, with no limit; AirVPN allows five.
No; it accepts anonymous sign-up and cryptocurrency.
The Verdict
PIA vs AirVPN: PIA for audited, all-round use with port forwarding; AirVPN for open-source transparency and anonymity.